Channel 4 to keep screening controversial Paddy Power ad

Be Sociable, Share!

Broadcaster has no plans to drop ‘transgendered ladies’ advert despite 500 complaints and ESPN pulling it

Channel 4 has no plans to drop a controversial “transgendered ladies” ad by bookmaker Paddy Power despite almost 500 complaints to the advertising watchdog, which have prompted a rival broadcaster to drop the campaign.

Channel 4′s stance is at odds with US sports giant ESPN, which was also scheduled to air the TV ad ahead of the Cheltenham racing festival, which has now pulled the campaign from its network.

“We’ve reviewed the commercial in question, and have made an internal editorial decision that it will not run on ESPN,” said a spokesman for ESPN.

Channel 4 said it had a “duty” to make sure that any ads it airs are fully compliant with the advertising code.

A spokesman for the channel said it was the broadcaster’s policy to leave it “up to our viewers to make their own judgment about the adverts they have seen”.

The Paddy Power advert asks viewers to spot the “transgendered ladies” among a crowd of racing fans at the Cheltenham festival.

It was accused of inciting transphobia with the campaign, which promised to make the festival’s Ladies’ Day “even more exciting by adding some beautiful transgendered ladies: Spot the stallions from the mares”.

The ad goes on to show a series of shots of well-dressed racegoers with a voiceover guessing which are men and which are women.

Paddy Power said the ad, which has already been broadcast by Sky Sports, had been given the green light by official body Clearcast.

Clearcast pre-vets TV ads to try to ensure they will not break the advertising code governed by the Advertising Standards Authority.

The ASA, which has received 473 complaints about the campaign, has launched an investigation to see if it is in breach of the code.

Paddy Power and BSkyB have been criticised by the lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender community. BSkyB has said that it has no intention of pulling the ad from its channels.

A spokesman for BSkyB said: “Prior to transmission all advertising is checked by Clearcast, an independent body dedicated to applying the ASA rules and regulations on advertising. If, retrospectively, any ad is thought unsuitable for broadcast, the ASA can step in. When they do so, we always comply with the judgments they make.”

LGBT Lib Dems Northern Ireland said Paddy Power had brought “shame on itself” and that the marketing tactic was in poor taste at a time when the UK government is trying to wipe out all forms of prejudice in sport.

“To use the subject of transgender in such a degrading and mocking way is a clear-cut case of transphobia,” said the organisation on its website.

Paddy Power said the ad was a bit of “mild-mannered fun” in the runup to the Cheltenham festival.

The CheltenhamFestival.net website said the campaign was “tongue in cheek” but admitted that some people have found it “in poor taste”.

Paddy Power is no stranger to controversy, having recently featured Imogen Thomas in a football ad campaign titled “Blow Me” in a bid to capitalise on the publicity surrounding Ryan Giggs’s affair.

In 2010 the bookmaker aired what was to become the most complained-about ad of the year featuring blind footballers kicking a cat.

Invited to add their comments, visitors to the site branded it “a disgrace” and “simply horrendous”. “I have never seen such an insensitive hate ad,” wrote Alex Kennedy.

• To contact the MediaGuardian news desk email editor@mediaguardian.co.uk or phone 020 3353 3857. For all other inquiries please call the main Guardian switchboard on 020 3353 2000. If you are writing a comment for publication, please mark clearly “for publication”.

• To get the latest media news to your desktop or mobile, follow MediaGuardian on Twitter and Facebook.


guardian.co.uk © 2012 Guardian News and Media Limited or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved. | Use of this content is subject to our Terms & Conditions | More Feeds

Be Sociable, Share!

Paddy Power faces investigation over ‘transgendered ladies’ ad

Be Sociable, Share!

ASA launches inquiry after hundreds of complaints about TV campaign asking viewers to ‘spot the stallions from the mares’

The advertising regulator is to investigate a TV ad by Irish bookmaker Paddy Power that asks viewers to spot the “transgendered ladies” among a crowd of racing fans at the Cheltenham festival.

The Advertising Standards Authority received 360 complaints that the campaign is offensive towards transgender people.

Paddy Power and broadcaster BSkyB were accused of inciting transphobia with the campaign, which promised to make the festival’s Ladies’ Day “even more exciting by adding some beautiful transgendered ladies: Spot the stallions from the mares”.

The ad goes on to show a series of shots of well-dressed racegoers with a voiceover guessing which are men and which are women.

The campaign, which broadcast on Sky Sports at the weekend, immediately drew criticism from the lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender community.

LGBT Lib Dems Northern Ireland said Paddy Power has brought “shame on itself” and that the marketing tactic was in poor taste at a time when the UK government is trying to wipe out all forms of prejudice in sport.

“To use the subject of transgender in such a degrading and mocking way is a clear-cut case of transphobia,” said the organisation on its website.

“What is worse is that the advert appeared during Sky Sports’ very popular Soccer Saturday not just once but three times. So while we have the UK government running a campaign to wipe out transphobia in sport we have the nation’s number one sports channel showing such an advert.”

Paddy Power is no stranger to controversy, having recently featured Imogen Thomas in an ad campaign in a bid to capitalise on the publicity surrounding Ryan Giggs’s affair.

In 2010 the bookmaker aired what was to become the most complained-about ad of the year featuring blind footballers kicking a cat.

The CheltenhamFestival.net website said the campaign was “tongue in cheek” but admitted that some people have found it “in poor taste”.

Invited to add their comments, visitors to the site branded it “a disgrace” and “simply horrendous”. “I have never seen such an insensitive hate ad,” wrote Alex Kennedy.

Stephen Glenn wrote: “We have a government that is working to get homophobia and transphobia out of sport. Yet we have a betting company linking this gross advert to the name of the Cheltenham Festival. I don’t think the staff for Cheltenham should be asking us what we think of this but should have condemned it outright themselves.”

A spokesman for Paddy Power said that the ad campaign has generated “plenty of public response” which it says has been “healthily mixed”.

“Several members of the UK transgender community are cast in the ad, and it was also cleared by Clearcast [which pre-vets TV ads] before airing,” said Paddy Power. ” This ad is simply a bit of mild-mannered fun in the runup to the Cheltenham festival.”

• To contact the MediaGuardian news desk email editor@mediaguardian.co.uk or phone 020 3353 3857. For all other inquiries please call the main Guardian switchboard on 020 3353 2000. If you are writing a comment for publication, please mark clearly “for publication”.

• To get the latest media news to your desktop or mobile, follow MediaGuardian on Twitter and Facebook.


guardian.co.uk © 2012 Guardian News and Media Limited or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved. | Use of this content is subject to our Terms & Conditions | More Feeds

Be Sociable, Share!

Jockey Club chief faces big hurdles

Be Sociable, Share!

Simon Bazalgette, chief executive of British horse racing’s largest commercial body, is about to take a huge gamble on revamping the home of the famous Cheltenham Festival

Simon Bazalgette, the chief executive of the Jockey Club, is considering a multimillion pound punt. The person dubbed the “most powerful man in British horse racing” holds the reins of 14 British racing tracks and, despite all the woes of the credit crunch, he is now contemplating a grand and lavish project to revamp the famous course at Cheltenham.

“Obviously financing big projects is much harder now,” he admits. “Over the next three, four, five years [Cheltenham is] probably the major bit of capital investment that we would like to make across the Jockey Club. We are working through various feasibility plans at the moment. We have a reasonable amount of bank debt. At the height we probably had £130m to £140m of debt. We are now down to between £90m and £100m. And that’s reducing significantly this year. I’m sure debt will be a part of [the Cheltenham redevelopment].”

It is not clear just how much a revamp of Cheltenham would cost, although £30m has been spent at Epsom and £25m on Aintree. While raising debt may be challenging in these markets, the famous festival course is crucial to the club and the man running it.

Industry gossips reckon Cheltenham accounts for about half of its £18.3m operating profit (the Jockey Club says it is impossible to split out and that the course is a “key source”, but contributes less than half, of revenues).

Still, Cheltenham management believes a redevelopment is long overdue and racing rumours suggest it is about to use its sway to achieve what it wants. Some suggest building work could start immediately after the 2014 Cheltenham Festival, but Bazalgette is unmoved. “It is still at an early stage,” he blocks. He gives little further ground, which is what you might expect from a man of coming from such a successful bloodline. The great, great-grandson of Sir Joseph Bazalgette, the designer of London’s sewers, he is also a cousin of media entrepreneur Peter Bazalgette, who brought Big Brother to British television audiences and promoted the format all around the world.

Bazalgette of the Jockey Club also made his name in the media business, having founded pay television channel Music Choice Europe, before, in 2004, joining Racing UK, the fledgling horse racing channel owned by a collection of courses, many from the Jockey Club’s own stable. He is now using the tricks he learned within the world of broadcasting in an attempt to rebrand racing, which can sometimes seem impenetrable to the outsider. His latest effort is the introduction of the British Champions Series, launched in April, which is an attempt to provide some coherence to the flat racing season in the wake of the aborted Sovereign Series.

It is basically a brand that wraps around the great flat meetings such as the Guineas, the Derby, Royal Ascot and Glorious Goodwood, and culminates in the British Champions Day, the UK’s richest race day with more than £3m in prize money. It all got off to a decent start this year with the emergence of an equine superstar, Frankel, the 2000 Guineas and Queen Elizabeth II Stakes winner, but it is still not clear what the series is intended to be.

Bazalgette peppers the rationale behind the series with management-speak. It has been about “creating a vehicle” or it is “a platform to help create a larger [racing] economy”, he says, claims demonstrated by the “multi-million pound” sponsorship deal signed with Qatari investment firm Qipco.

Aficionado

However, the corporate waffle is more easily deciphered than the series’ actual structure, especially if you are not a racing aficionado. Horses do not accumulate points to qualify for Champions Day as you might expect. In fact, as long as the horse has a high enough rating, it can just turn up to the finale.

“It’s [a] simple [system] for racing but slightly more complicated than for any other sport,” admits Bazalgette, who is actually more of a football fan and supports Brentford. “We recognise part of the challenge is to start to bring in more formal mechanics, whether it’s a bonus prize, whether it’s league tables, whether it’s qualification, you can debate that. We recognise this is only the starting point”.

The other big issue on his desk goes back to his broadcasting roots and relates to which channel punters will be watching racing on from 2013. Budgets at BBC Sport, which broadcasts the Grand National, the Derby and Royal Ascot, have been cut by around 15%. With renegotiations on broadcast rights now under way, there is speculation that the BBC might prefer to spend its dwindling reserves on the big Aintree steeplechase rather than keep covering the other events.

Meanwhile, can the current Channel 4 deal, in which racing subsidises the broadcaster’s costs, continue? “My own view is that [the BBC will] want to keep the National and that they’ll fight to keep it,” Bazalgette says. “The environment for the last broadcast deal was very difficult, which came just as the advertising market was collapsing and ITV and Channel 4 were in complete crisis. That’s not the way now. The advertising market has come back and is doing very well. There’s a lot more money around from bookmaker advertising in way that wasn’t the case three or four years ago. My view is that Channel 4 and even ITV will be very interested now. The value to Channel 4 of racing is lot more than it was three to four years ago and I’d think that will be reflected in next round of discussions”.

Sluggish

Other media revenues from Racing UK – and its spin-off Turf TV – in which the Jockey Club is a shareholder will also increase from 2013, but until then Bazalgette admits that the club faces a “tough” 2012 as it operates in a sluggish economy and competes for corporate hospitality customers in Olympic year.

Jockey Club profits are recycled into racing, – not into shareholders’ pockets – so that perhaps explains why, despite having the technology ready, Bazalgette seems reluctant to invest in a high definition channel for Racing UK subscribers. It is also why Cheltenham and the Champions Series are such big deals. There is a lot riding on them.


guardian.co.uk © 2012 Guardian News and Media Limited or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved. | Use of this content is subject to our Terms & Conditions | More Feeds

Be Sociable, Share!